British journalists have crafted a rather subjective but fascinating symbolic XI of the most overrated players in the Premier League. This list includes representatives from the biggest clubs, such as Arsenal, Chelsea, Manchester City, and Manchester United.
Overrating, in this context, implies that the public praise and popularity of a player significantly exceed their actual abilities on the pitch. Compiling such a list is a complex task that invites debate, but it brilliantly highlights the issues surrounding some of the league's current stars.
Goalkeeper: Emiliano Martinez (Chelsea)
Martinez's move to Chelsea seemed like a major coup and an upgrade on Robert Sanchez. However, on the club level, he hasn't showcased the same phenomenal performances he delivers for the Argentina national team. Lately, Emiliano has been prone to costly errors, conceding several ridiculous goals while donning a Chelsea shirt.
Right-back: Tino Livramento (Newcastle)
Livramento is often touted as a coveted target for top clubs, with a price tag of £50 million. Surprisingly, despite limited attacking qualities on his preferred right flank, he appears much more assured on the left. As a right-back, he underwhelms, reminiscent of Aaron Wan-Bissaka with his struggles in the creative department.
Centre-backs: Levi Colwill (Chelsea) and Mickey van de Ven (Tottenham)
The hype around Colwill has noticeably dwindled following his ACL injury last year, yet Chelsea fans still cling to the belief in his talent. In reality, Levi tends to be rather sluggish, and his positional awareness leaves much to be desired.
Partnering him in this backline is our captain of the list, Mickey van de Ven. The Dutchman may well be the most overrated player in the world. His only elite trait—phenomenal pace—often bails him out after his own positional blunders. Without that burst of speed, he would likely be playing for a modest club like Go Ahead Eagles. Rumours linking him with Real Madrid seem like a bad joke, especially given Tottenham's dire defensive record, with van de Ven as a prime example.
Left-back: Antonee Robinson (Fulham)
Choosing a left-back was the toughest decision. Robinson makes this list largely because he was previously regarded as underrated, but public opinion has swung wildly in the opposite direction.
Central midfielders: Lucas Bergvall (Tottenham) and Adam Wharton (Crystal Palace)
In the case of 20-year-old Bergvall, the main issue lies in a complete lack of clarity regarding his role. No one seems quite sure what he actually is: a defensive midfielder, a destroyer, or a playmaker? His best and worst qualities remain a mystery.
Adam Wharton is undoubtedly a tidy and technical player, but the media often hails him as the new Toni Kroos. In reality, he fails to make the England squad, with competition getting the better of him, and top clubs repeatedly opting for other options in the transfer market, raising questions about his actual level.
Right winger: Bukayo Saka (Arsenal)
This inclusion strikes at the very heart of the Gunners' fanbase. Saka hasn't fizzled out as a player, but Mikel Arteta appears to have overburdened his star man. Bukayo has lost that distinctive pace and explosive speed that used to terrify opposition full-backs. It's disheartening to watch such a special talent being run into the ground.
Attacking midfielder: Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United)
Bruno was magnificent under Michael Carrick's management, but his true colours show when the chips are down. When things aren’t going well, Fernandes is often seen complaining, displaying abysmal body language and acting in ways a captain for United shouldn't. His style raises eyebrows as well; he's willing to make 14 careless passes for the sake of one perfect assist that will land him back in the 'genius' spotlight.
Left winger: Phil Foden (Manchester City)
Foden's stock has taken a nosedive since his triumphant 2023/24 season. He rarely takes control in tough moments, shining only when Pep Guardiola's team is cruising. His statistics for the England national team are quite poor: just four goals in 49 appearances. Yet, any absenteeism from the squad triggers monumental media outrage.
Striker: Bryan Brobbey (Sunderland)
Up front, the choice fell on Brobbey. He embodies the spirit of old-school forwards, being robust and charismatic, winning over fans. However, seven goals in the 2025/26 Premier League season is alarmingly low for a player with such promise. Supporters are simply turning a blind eye to his lack of output, dazzled by his exciting style of play.
