Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
Former referees’ chief Keith Hackett says VAR has made Premier League officials less independent and has called for changes to the system.

Former England referees’ chief Keith Hackett has criticised the use of VAR in the Premier League, saying it has made officials less independent and reduced the standard of refereeing.

Hackett, who previously held a senior role at PGMOL, compared VAR with the Hawk-Eye goal-line technology system, which he helped to introduce.

Unfortunately, I cannot say unequivocally that the introduction of VAR has had the same positive effect as Hawk-Eye.

In my view, the system encourages ‘lazy’ refereeing. This is particularly noticeable when I see obvious fouls in the penalty area and referees are slow to make decisions. Essentially, excessive reliance on VAR has undermined the authority of the referee on the pitch.

Hackett cited Liverpool’s match against Arsenal as an example, when Jurrien Timber held Alexander Isak’s shirt as they challenged for an aerial ball. In Hackett’s view, referee Andy Madley and video assistant Stuart Attwell were wrong not to award a penalty.

Hackett proposed appointing dedicated VAR specialists, holding weekly reviews of contentious decisions and introducing an automated offside system without manually drawn lines.

VAR still has a very long way to go before fans begin to trust it. The main reason is the excessive number of incorrect decisions made so far.