Raul Jimenez remains the most reliable penalty taker in Premier League history among players who have taken at least 10. The Mexican has scored all 14 of his attempts, putting him ahead of Yaya Toure, Matt Le Tissier, Bukayo Saka and other renowned specialists.
Jimenez's key achievement is his perfect record. After scoring a penalty against Manchester United in February 2026, he took his tally to 14 goals from 14 attempts and moved into outright first place for the most penalties scored with a 100% conversion rate.
The record previously belonged to Yaya Toure. The former Manchester City midfielder took 11 Premier League penalties and scored every one. Seven of those goals proved to be winners, while five put his team ahead.
The Premier League's best penalty takers
Among players who have taken at least 10 penalties, the best records are:
- Raul Jimenez — 14 from 14, 100%
- Yaya Toure — 11 from 11, 100%
- Matt Le Tissier — 25 from 26, 96.2%
- Danny Murphy — 18 from 19, 94.7%
- Callum Wilson — 16 from 17, 94.1%
- James Beattie — 16 from 17, 94.1%
- Julian Dicks — 15 from 16, 93.8%
- Bukayo Saka — 13 from 14, 92.9%
- Thierry Henry — 23 from 25, 92%
- Ivan Toney — 11 from 12, 91.7%
- Alexander Isak — 11 from 12, 91.7%
- Bryan Mbeumo — 10 from 11, 90.9%
- Leighton Baines — 20 from 22, 90.9%
- Cole Palmer — 19 from 21, 90.5%
- James Milner — 18 from 20, 90%
Palmer also had a perfect record for a long time. After scoring twice from the spot against Tottenham in December 2024, he had 12 goals from 12 attempts, but his penalty against Leicester in March 2025 was saved.
Mbeumo had a similar experience. In spring 2025, he joined the group of players with at least 10 penalties and a 100% conversion rate, but Bernd Leno ended his perfect run on 18 May.
Ivan Toney also started without a miss, scoring his first 10 penalties. In April 2023, however, he failed to convert his 11th attempt against Newcastle, although he later scored from the spot in the same match.
Le Tissier did miss
Matt Le Tissier has an almost mythical reputation as a penalty specialist, but he did miss once in the Premier League. In March 1993, Nottingham Forest's Mark Crossley saved his effort.
It was only Le Tissier's third Premier League penalty. He went on to score his next 23 attempts in a row and never missed again.
His final record was 25 goals from 26 penalties, or 96.2%.
Saka already among the best
Bukayo Saka is also high up the all-time rankings. The Arsenal player has scored 13 of his 14 Premier League penalties, giving him a conversion rate of 92.9%.
Thierry Henry scored 23 from 25, with neither of his misses saved by the goalkeeper. On both occasions the Frenchman hit the post, against Jussi Jaaskelainen and Antti Niemi.
Who has scored the most penalties?
Alan Shearer is the all-time Premier League leader for both penalties taken and goals scored from the spot. He took 67 and scored 56.
Next by goals scored are Frank Lampard with 43, Mohamed Salah with 35, Harry Kane with 33, Steven Gerrard with 32, Mark Noble and Bruno Fernandes with 28 each, and Sergio Aguero and Jamie Vardy with 27 each.
Shearer also shares the record for the most missed penalties, with 11. Wayne Rooney missed as many, while Teddy Sheringham missed 10.
Kluivert's unique hat-trick
On 30 November 2024, Justin Kluivert set a unique Premier League record. Against Wolverhampton, the Bournemouth player became the first footballer in the competition's history to score a hat-trick of penalties in one match.
His team-mate Evanilson became the first Premier League player to win three penalties in a single match in the same game.
The Premier League's worst penalty takers
At the other end of the rankings is Juan Pablo Angel. Among players with at least 10 attempts, he has the lowest conversion rate at just 50%.
The Colombian scored five of his 10 penalties for Aston Villa. A match against Fulham in February 2005 was particularly unsuccessful for him, as Edwin van der Sar saved two of his penalties less than six minutes apart.
Next on the list of the worst are Steed Malbranque and Dwight Yorke on 60% each, Kevin Phillips on 61.1%, Aleksandar Mitrovic on 61.5%, and Wilfried Zaha and Paul Pogba on 63.6% each.
Among players who have taken at least 20 penalties, Michael Owen has the worst record: 14 goals from 21 attempts, or 66.7%. Rooney follows on 67.6%.
Juninho holds a separate unwanted record: the Brazilian took four Premier League penalties and did not score any of them.