The Premier League's Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel reviewed controversial refereeing decisions in three matches before the international break.
Arsenal beat Hull 1-0, but the panel unanimously ruled that the hosts should have been awarded a penalty after Nobel Mendy pulled Kai Havertz in the box. Referee Farai Hallam penalised the German forward for offside, but the panel found that the foul occurred before Havertz became involved in an offside situation.
“Although Havertz was clearly in an offside position, Mendy committed a clear and sustained hold before any possible offside offence,” the panel said.
The panel also ruled that a penalty awarded against Liverpool in their match against Crystal Palace was incorrect. Palace lost the match 3-1. Milos Kerkez and Dario Osorio clashed heads, after which the referee pointed to the spot. Eddie Nketiah converted the penalty.
All five members of the panel agreed that the decision was incorrect because the contact between the players was unavoidable. However, the incident did not meet the threshold for VAR intervention.
“The penalty was incorrectly awarded because the contact was unavoidable. However, it was not a clear and obvious error,” the panel said.
In Chelsea's 1-0 defeat to Sunderland, the panel backed the officials' decisions.
Chelsea were unhappy that they were not awarded a penalty after Cole Palmer went down in a challenge with Luke O'Nien. The panel agreed that there was a foul, but the contact occurred outside the penalty area, so VAR could not intervene.
The panel also unanimously endorsed the penalty awarded against Chelsea for Levi Colwill's foul on Brian Brobbey.
The panel therefore found that refereeing decisions had incorrectly favoured Arsenal's and Liverpool's opponents, while all the contentious incidents in Chelsea's match against Sunderland were assessed correctly. It was the fourth time this season that the panel had identified a refereeing error in favour of a Liverpool opponent.