Michael Carrick's departure as Manchester United head coach was the logical, if shocking, outcome of a deep crisis. Not long ago, the team appeared to have found their form: after his appointment on 13 January 2026, Carrick took 39 points from his first 17 Premier League matches, turning United into the competition's most formidable force. That run was built on four pillars: a lighter schedule without European football, an ideally balanced midfield of Casemiro, Kobbie Mainoo and Bruno Fernandes, effective set-pieces and a clear style of play that meant they rarely had to come from behind.
But the summer transfer window dismantled what had worked so well. The departure of the highly paid Casemiro, without any attempt to extend his contract, left a gap in midfield. New arrivals Andrey Santos, Youri Tielemans and Carlos Baleba have been unable to replace the Brazilian's leadership, reading of the game and aerial ability. The situation at full-back, where United remained the weakest of the Premier League's top six clubs, compounded the problems.
Experts rightly point to systemic mistakes by the leadership under Jim Ratcliffe. In February 2024, Ratcliffe said that the coaches could not be blamed for everything. Yet in a short space of time, he reversed the decision to sack Erik ten Hag, dismissed sporting director Dan Ashworth and sacked Ruben Amorim just three months after saying he needed to be given three years. Mauricio Pochettino has replaced Carrick, but the root of the club's problems lies less in managerial dismissals than in the strategic chaos at the top.