Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
Mauricio Pochettino has replaced Michael Carrick at Manchester United, an appointment offering promise but carrying serious risks.

Mauricio Pochettino's long-awaited appointment as Manchester United head coach has finally come. A decade after Sir Alex Ferguson took the Argentine out for lunch in London, the former Tottenham, PSG, Chelsea and United States manager has replaced Michael Carrick at Old Trafford.

United's hierarchy decided not to miss the opportunity, paying around £7.4 million in compensation to the US Soccer Federation and a further £5 million for his coaching staff. But the financial details will be secondary if the Argentine cannot pull the team out of a deep crisis. United are in the relegation zone at a later stage of the season than at any point since the 1986–87 campaign, with a crucial test against Liverpool to come.

Strengths and historical context

Pochettino's greatest asset is his successful spell at Tottenham, where he established an exciting, attacking and high-energy style built on pressing high up the pitch. He turned Spurs into genuine title contenders and took them to the Champions League final. His philosophy is based on developing young players, building team unity and creating an emotional connection with the stands, qualities that fit United's traditions.

His successful work with the United States ahead of their home World Cup also demonstrated his ability to change a team's mentality and instil belief in its players. Pochettino demands total commitment, something vital for United, who are among the Premier League's worst teams this season for distance covered and the number of high-intensity pressing actions.

Pitfalls and risks

Nevertheless, the move to Manchester United carries enormous reputational risks. None of the club's permanent managers since Alex Ferguson left has departed with an enhanced reputation. On the contrary, the last five are unlikely to receive offers from top Premier League clubs any time soon.

Pochettino's career since leaving Tottenham also raises questions. At PSG, with a star-studded squad featuring Neymar, Kylian Mbappe and Lionel Messi, he won only a couple of domestic trophies and missed out on the league title. His sole season at Chelsea was marked by inconsistent results and a record disciplinary tally of 105 yellow and four red cards. Critics also point to his poor record in finals, with defeats in cup finals with Tottenham, Chelsea and the United States, and his reliance on elite players such as Harry Kane and Son Heung-min.

Pochettino's arrival at Manchester United brings enormous potential and high expectations, but the scale of the club's problems is such that even the Argentine coach's “magic” will face unprecedented resistance.