Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
BBC Sport's Umir Irfan argues that Mauricio Pochettino could address the tactical problems Michael Carrick faced at Manchester United.

Mauricio Pochettino's appointment as Manchester United head coach marks a new chapter for a club at a crossroads after Michael Carrick's departure. Writing in his tactical column for BBC Sport, Umir Irfan argues that the Argentine has a unique combination of qualities and ideas that could finally unite two opposing sides of the club's philosophy: those who favour results at any cost and those who defend the attacking style associated with Alex Ferguson's era.

Pochettino's connection to Sir Alex's legacy runs throughout his career. In 2023, while managing Chelsea, he repeated the Scottish manager's name three times in a Sky Sports interview when asked which coaches he would have dreamed of playing for. Years earlier, as Tottenham manager, Pochettino had a two-hour lunch with the former United boss, whom he has consistently named as his greatest inspiration in coaching.

Tactical analysis: why Pochettino could overcome Carrick's problems

Michael Carrick's tenure left a mixed impression. On the one hand, his team produced an impressive run at the end of last season, proving highly effective in transition. The statistics bear this out: United won 62% of their matches in which they had less than 50% possession, losing only once. Direct attacks and exploiting open spaces suited their quick attacking players, while set pieces taken by Casemiro helped break down deep defences.

However, Carrick's attempt to reshape the team around positional football, short passing and possession-based dominance failed — just as Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Erik ten Hag had encountered the same obstacle. When United were forced to take the initiative, their win rate fell sharply, while their rigid 4-2-4 defensive shape stopped working as opponents adapted to their risky high press.

Pochettino offers a different solution. A follower of Marcelo Bielsa, the Argentine builds his teams around direct, dynamic and physically demanding football, similar in philosophy to Andoni Iraola's approach at Brighton or Liverpool. The most recent World Cup demonstrated the evolution of Pochettino's tactics with the United States: rather than using rigid positional structures, he deployed a fluid midfield quartet with players moving into open spaces and constantly exchanging positions. This disrupted opponents' zonal defences and created shooting opportunities for a forward such as Folarin Balogun.

Pochettino's principles are in many ways similar to what Carrick tried unsuccessfully to achieve: giving players freedom within a well-organised team. The difference is that Pochettino has extensive experience and the ability to establish a well-coordinated press and high levels of fitness, as demonstrated by his successful work with Cole Palmer at Chelsea. If the Argentine can instil that intensity in the team and bring out the strengths of their leading attackers, Manchester United will receive a much-needed boost. The main challenge, however, remains breaking down packed defences through positional attacking play.