Chelsea are still struggling to establish a playing identity under Xabi Alonso. Their 1-0 defeat at Sunderland provided further evidence that constant changes to the formation and line-up have yet to bring consistency.
As BBC Sport journalist Nizaar Kinsella notes, the Spaniard is increasingly reminiscent of the “Tinkerman” – the nickname given to former Chelsea manager Claudio Ranieri in the early 2000s because of his tendency to make frequent changes.
Xabi Alonso's constant experiments
Against Sunderland, Chelsea used three central midfielders for the first time this season. Once again, they were without a specialist centre-forward, with Pedro Neto deployed up front for the second match running.
The hosts, by contrast, opted for powerful centre-forward Brian Brobbey. He won a penalty in the 36th minute when Levi Colwill fouled him, and Enzo Le Fee converted the spot-kick to decide the match.
Shortly before that, Chelsea had claimed a penalty of their own after Cole Palmer went down in a challenge with Luke O'Nien, but VAR determined that the contact began outside the penalty area.
After the match, Alonso did not criticise the officiating but expressed dissatisfaction with his own players.
“No, he can be stopped. But we should have done better than we did today. He got a few chances and won a penalty from almost nothing. I didn't like how we defended in that situation. It could have been avoided; we worked on situations like that in training. Conceding goals from penalties is bad for us,” the manager said, commenting on Brobbey's performance.
Colwill was substituted at half-time, with Moises Caicedo taking his place in central defence. Caicedo had barely trained fully during the week and needed his own fitness to be managed.
Injuries make a settled line-up difficult to find
According to BBC Sport, only Tottenham have made more changes to their starting line-up than Chelsea in the Premier League this season: 28 compared with Chelsea's 24.
Early in the campaign, Alonso was able to use a more settled attacking trio of Joao Pedro, Morgan Rogers and Palmer. Injuries, however, gradually forced him to change formation and look for new combinations.
Among those unavailable are Joao Pedro, who suffered a thigh injury, captain Reece James and goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez, who broke his jaw in a collision with an Everton player. Maxence Lacroix, who joined from Crystal Palace in the summer, is not expected to return until January because of a hamstring injury. Jorrel Hato has also had health problems.
Alonso acknowledged that the availability of players is limiting his options when selecting his team.
“There are certain circumstances. Yesterday Josh Acheampong said he wasn't ready to play, so our options are limited. We need to get through this period. Whether we win or lose, we miss the injured players. We are waiting for them to return because they are important to the team,” the Spaniard explained.
Fans have also expressed dissatisfaction with Estevao Willian's limited playing time. The Brazilian came on at half-time against Sunderland but had previously started just once in the league.
Possession fails to deliver results
The match against Sunderland highlighted another problem for Chelsea. They had 68.7% of possession but failed to create enough dangerous chances.
The season's statistics nevertheless show that Chelsea's matches often feature plenty of threat at both ends. Only Crystal Palace have allowed their opponents more shots on target than Chelsea, who have conceded 50. At the same time, Chelsea lead the league for shots on target with 53.
That underlines the team's inconsistency: Chelsea can create chances but also regularly allow opponents to threaten their own goal.
Xabi Alonso is still far from a solution
Despite the defeat, Chelsea's position in the table remains relatively good. They have five more points than at the same stage last season and sit fifth, with Champions League qualification still a possibility.
However, after finishing tenth in the previous campaign, those figures have yet to dispel questions about Alonso's work. In ten Premier League matches under the Spaniard, Chelsea have won five, lost four and drawn one.
Before the November international break, Chelsea still lack a clearly defined playing style. Alonso previously promised that the team would be different and playing better by the end of the season, but his experiments with tactics and selection have yet to provide the consistency needed.