Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
An analysis of five reasons why appointing Mauricio Pochettino could be a high-risk move for Manchester United and might end in failure.

Mauricio Pochettino has emerged as the leading candidate to replace Michael Carrick as Manchester United head coach. But appointing the Argentine would carry serious risks for a club who have made a disastrous start to the season and sit 18th in the relegation zone with just eight points from ten games.

1. A lack of club trophies

Despite his extensive Premier League experience and his run to the 2019 Champions League final with Tottenham Hotspur, Pochettino still has no major club successes on his record. For a team whose ambitions and expectations have historically centred on winning titles, that could be a serious cause for concern.

2. Mixed spells at top clubs

His spells at Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea left a mixed impression. In France, despite winning Ligue 1, his team failed to achieve success in the Champions League. At Chelsea in 2023/24, he finished sixth and reached the EFL Cup final, but left after just one year because of disagreements with the club's management.

3. Conflicts with club management

Pochettino's career shows frequent dissatisfaction with clubs' transfer policies and strategies. The Argentine has repeatedly expressed frustration when personnel decisions have clashed with his vision. United's current structure under INEOS could provoke similar conflicts if the two sides do not reach a full understanding on squad development.

4. Tactical doubts and the fight for survival

The high-intensity pressing Pochettino favours may not suit United's current squad. Making radical tactical changes midway through a season, with the team in the relegation zone and suffering from chronic inconsistency, would be extremely risky.

5. Mixed results with the United States

Pochettino's latest role in charge of the United States national team has also exposed some of his limitations against genuinely strong opponents. At Old Trafford, a new manager would be expected to deliver immediate results, and the pressure at a Premier League giant in crisis would far exceed that of any international assignment.