Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
Stefan Borson believes Everton made a costly mistake letting Dominic Calvert-Lewin leave for Leeds, where he has scored 20 goals.

Everton could come to regret allowing Dominic Calvert-Lewin to leave as a free agent in the summer of 2025. The striker has already scored 20 goals for Leeds, while David Moyes has virtually no alternative to Thierno Barry. Former Manchester City financial adviser Stefan Borson has called the Englishman's departure a very expensive mistake.

Calvert-Lewin left Everton after nine years at the club. The parties were unable to agree a new contract and the forward joined Leeds on a free transfer in August 2025.

The 29-year-old striker has found form at his new club and has already scored 20 times.

Everton did not give Moyes enough attacking options in the summer. Barry has scored 10 goals in 13 matches this season, but remains the manager's only recognised centre-forward.

‘It looks like a very, very expensive mistake’

In an interview with Football Insider, Borson questioned whether the financial differences between Everton and Calvert-Lewin were significant enough to justify losing the player.

“I wonder how far apart the parties were in negotiations. How big could the difference have been if Leeds were willing and able to pay him?

“It is unlikely to have been anything extraordinary. Suppose the difference was £50,000 a week. That is £2.5 million a year. And strikers like that now cost at least around £50 million.

“I am sure there is a lot of regret at the club over this deal. Of course, he had a lot of injury problems at Everton, but at Leeds he does not seem to have those difficulties any more.

“It was impossible to predict that in advance. But now it looks like a very, very expensive mistake. Everton could really have used Calvert-Lewin.”

Everton must avoid repeating the mistake with Thierno Barry

The club now face the task of keeping their current first-choice striker.

Barry is attracting increasing attention thanks to his goalscoring form, and he will soon have two years left on his contract.

Everton must also decide the future of Harrison Armstrong, whose deal runs until the summer of 2028.

A more urgent issue concerns Michael Keane. The experienced defender continues to play an important role in the team, but his contract expires next summer.

In Borson's view, Calvert-Lewin's case shows how costly it can be for a club to fail to reach an agreement with an important player in time.