Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
Pat Nevin says Estevao will probably need to leave Chelsea to fulfil his potential and believes Jarrad Branthwaite could strengthen their defence.

Former Chelsea, Everton and Scotland winger Pat Nevin has discussed Chelsea’s structural problems under Xabi Alonso, explained why moving Cole Palmer into the centre freed up the team, predicted Estevao’s departure and named the one defender he believes could solve the problem at Stamford Bridge for the next decade.

A dream attacking trio and a major defensive problem

Xabi Alonso’s start at Stamford Bridge has produced mixed impressions. On the one hand, the Spaniard has managed to bring Joao Pedro, Morgan Rogers and Cole Palmer together on the pitch, although doing so meant sacrificing Enzo Fernandez.

“He accepted that he had to let Enzo Fernandez go if he wanted to get what he wanted. It was a great decision. Enzo was at the very centre of the system, and now Cole and his close friend Morgan can link up much more effectively,” Nevin said.

But Chelsea’s longstanding problem has not gone away. Whether they play with two or three centre-backs, the defence looks vulnerable and concedes too many goals. In Nevin’s view, they cannot challenge for the title until that is addressed. The situation is made worse by injuries to Reece James, whom he sees as the ideal wing-back for a 3-4-2-1 formation. Without him, the flanks lose their balance.

The Estevao paradox: too good for the bench

Despite Brazilian prodigy Estevao’s impressive performance as a starter against Manchester United, Nevin is sceptical about his long-term prospects at Chelsea.

“You can’t take Palmer, Rogers or Joao Pedro out of the starting line-up, and 10–12 matches a season is nowhere near enough for a 19-year-old talent. To develop his football intelligence and learn how to make the right runs to receive the ball, the Brazilian needs to play 30–40 games a year. Training can’t replace that. I’ve been writing about this for a year and a half: Estevao will be a great footballer, but probably not at Chelsea. He’ll have to change clubs to fulfil his potential.”

Palmer’s field of vision and the Moises Caicedo factor

Moving Cole Palmer from the wing into a central position has been a key tactical decision by Alonso. Nevin explains it through the geometry of the pitch: on the touchline, a player has only around 30 degrees of vision to develop an attack, whereas as a No 8 or No 10, they have the full 160 degrees in front of them. Nevin nevertheless wants greater consistency from Palmer, describing his form as too variable.

In defensive midfield, Moises Caicedo remains the team’s foundation, providing the cover that allows his team-mates to play with three centre-backs. Alongside him, Alonso can rotate Jordan Henderson, Romeo Lavia and Reece James without disruption. At centre-back, though, Nevin believes maturity is lacking: being beaten in the physical battle by Brian Brobbey and Sunderland exposed the naivety of the young defenders, who generally only reach their peak at 26–28.

An Everton transfer target and a tightrope walk

If Chelsea could make just one signing to strengthen their starting line-up, Nevin would choose Everton centre-back Jarrad Branthwaite without hesitation, believing he could fill the position for the next 8–9 years.

Nevin is cautious, however, about Everton’s current high position in the European places:

“David Moyes is doing an amazing job, but the team have absolutely no squad depth. They need at least four or five quality players. If Thierno Barry or Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall is ruled out, they’ll have serious problems. And if Vitalii Mykolenko gets injured, there’s nobody to play on the left at all, so they have to put James Garner there. Everton are walking a tightrope.”

A rave in a Chelsea tracksuit

Looking back on his playing career in the 1980s, Nevin recalled an amusing story about tough Scottish defender Doug Rougvie, who put him up at the end of the season. To thank him, Nevin took his team-mate to an underground party in a south London warehouse, attended by a bohemian crowd and musician Boy George.

“The funniest thing was that Doug turned up in his Chelsea tracksuit. He looked completely out of place at this celebration of life,” the former player said with a smile.