Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
The IFR has proposed cash reserves for lower-division clubs, while Premier League clubs would face individual risk assessments rather than a common minimum.

The Independent Football Regulator (IFR) has proposed requiring English clubs to build up cash reserves to help them withstand financial crises. Premier League clubs would be treated differently for now, with no common minimum reserve requirement.

The proposals were published on 10 November, with financial analyst Paul Quinn examining them in detail on The Esk website the following day. The reform focuses on clubs' ability to meet their financial obligations independently, even if an owner suddenly stops funding the team.

94% of clubs operating at a loss

The reform follows a wide-ranging study of English football's finances published by the regulator in October.

It found that 94% of clubs in the top five divisions ended the 2025/26 season at a loss, despite English football's combined revenues exceeding £9 billion.

The situation is particularly concerning outside the Premier League. More than 60% of English Football League and National League clubs have debts exceeding the book value of their assets.

Another finding showed that 29% of clubs reported they would not survive even 30 days without further cash injections from their owners.

That means some clubs could struggle to pay wages and meet day-to-day costs almost immediately if their owners stopped supporting them.

How much would clubs have to hold in reserve?

The regulator proposes dividing English Football League clubs and those in the top division of the National League into three categories based on financial risk.

For the most financially stable clubs, the minimum reserve would be enough to pay all employees' wages for one month.

Clubs at medium risk would also need a reserve covering two months of forecast operating cash losses. For the clubs at greatest risk, that figure would rise to five months.

Not all assets would count

At least two-thirds of the required reserve must consist of unrestricted cash, certain categories of government bonds or investments in money market funds.

The remainder could, subject to additional conditions, be covered by certain guaranteed payments from transfers that have already been agreed.

Owners' promises to provide money in future, unused credit facilities and the estimated value of players would not count as a full reserve.

Why are the Premier League clubs treated differently?

The most controversial part of the proposals is the decision not to set a common minimum reserve for Premier League clubs for now.

The regulator says top-flight clubs have substantially greater financial resources and better access to commercial finance.

That does not mean they would be exempt from scrutiny. Each Premier League club would undergo an individual financial risk assessment, and the regulator could require additional cash reserves where necessary.

Writing in The Esk, Paul Quinn criticised the approach. In his view, the lack of a common baseline requirement for the Premier League remains one of the reform's main shortcomings.

The analyst notes that wealthy clubs can also face financial problems, particularly if a significant share of their commitments depends on future income, loans or support from owners.

Transfer debts will also be examined

The financial checks will not be limited to bank accounts.

From May 2028, clubs will have to submit detailed financial plans annually. The regulator intends to analyse debts, cash flow, reliance on owners and future transfer payments.

Particular attention will be paid to scenarios in which a club loses its main source of funding, is relegated or faces a 10% fall in revenue.

Clubs will have to show how they intend to cope with such circumstances.

When will the new rules take effect?

The reform is planned to take several years. The first individual financial reserve requirements are expected to be set in 2027.

Clubs will have to build up at least one-third of the required amount by summer 2028, two-thirds by 2029 and meet their requirements in full by summer 2030.

The system has not yet been finalised. Public consultation on the proposals will run until 18 December 2026, after which the regulator may make changes.

The reform's main aim is not to prevent clubs spending money on players, but to ensure that spending and debts do not threaten their existence.

Even a financial buffer will not solve every problem, however. A reserve can help a club through a temporary crisis, but it will not eliminate chronic losses if expenditure continues to exceed income.