Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
Carlton Cole says Manchester United should have sold Diogo Dalot, but Michael Carrick defended the defender after fans booed him in the 4-4 draw with Aston Villa.

Former England striker Carlton Cole has criticised Manchester United defender Diogo Dalot, saying the club should have parted company with the Portuguese player years ago.

Cole believes Dalot is incredibly fortunate to be at Old Trafford and that his repeated mistakes have long been a problem for the team.

Dalot, 27, has played for Manchester United since 2018, when the club paid Porto £19 million for him. The defender has made more than 250 appearances in that time.

When United signed Dalot, then-manager Jose Mourinho called him the best young full-back in Europe. However, Dalot has repeatedly come under criticism in recent years.

The past two weeks have been particularly difficult for him. The defender struggled against Roma in the Champions League and then made an error that led to a penalty in the 4-4 draw with Aston Villa.

When Dalot was substituted, Manchester United fans initially cheered Michael Carrick’s decision before booing the player himself.

‘Did he win the lottery?’: Carlton Cole criticises Dalot

On The Dressing Room podcast, Cole criticised both the defender and the Manchester United manager’s decisions.

“Some of the responsibility lies with Michael Carrick too. He puts certain players on the pitch and I look at them and think, ‘How are you still here?’

“I’ve said this before, but Diogo Dalot – how can he still be in the team?

“He’s nowhere near the required level. You can’t rely on him. All he thinks about is his next pay cheque. That’s what’s on his mind.

“He’s not worried about keeping the manager in his job. He probably can’t believe his luck: playing at Old Trafford in front of magnificent fans, in a wonderful stadium with so much history.

“Did he just win the lottery? I don’t understand how he gets on the pitch. He keeps making the same mistakes, letting opponents get past him time and again. He was at fault last week and made another mistake at the weekend.”

Michael Carrick defends Diogo Dalot after fans boo him

After the draw with Aston Villa, the Manchester United manager addressed the fans’ frustration.

Carrick acknowledged the Portuguese defender’s mistakes but stressed that he had no doubts about his commitment to the team.

“I think we need to be careful here. I understand the fans’ frustration and disappointment. I understand how they feel.

“We’re all frustrated and disappointed. And the players feel it just as much as anyone, I can guarantee you that.

“Diogo gives absolutely everything. He’s played in different positions, played on the left in defence and at times has done really well.

“Today he gave away a penalty. He knows that himself. Perhaps he could have done a little better. Yes, he made a mistake; these things happen.

“But he cares deeply and gives everything.

“I like what he brings to the team, the group and the whole atmosphere within the club.

“But selection for the next match is a completely different question. We have another game ahead of us to prepare for.”

Carrick did not guarantee Dalot a place in the team for the next match.

Manchester United drop into the relegation zone

The draw with Aston Villa extended United’s winless Premier League run to eight matches.

They head into the November international break 18th in the table.

The poor start to the 2026/27 season has increased the pressure on Carrick. According to Metro, his dismissal is becoming increasingly likely, with Eddie Howe considered the leading candidate to become Manchester United’s next manager.