Read full Brief ⚡Full 📖
15-Second Brief
James Copley dismissed claims that Granit Xhaka feigned injury to avoid facing Chelsea, calling them a conspiracy theory without convincing evidence.

Journalist James Copley has dismissed claims that Sunderland captain Granit Xhaka invented an injury to avoid playing against Chelsea, with whom he held talks in the summer.

Xhaka left the pitch in the fourth minute of the match.

Some fans then suggested on social media that the midfielder did not want to face Chelsea, given his previous talks over a possible move.

Copley strongly disagreed with that interpretation.

In my opinion, that is complete nonsense.

You can criticise Xhaka's performances, and I have done so myself.

But questioning his attitude towards the club without a single piece of convincing evidence is a conspiracy theory.

The journalist pointed out that the 34-year-old midfielder had played three matches in a week. After the game against Dinamo Zagreb, Regis Le Bris said he had not originally planned to keep his captain on the pitch until the end.

Xhaka, however, wanted to continue playing and help the team.

In Copley's view, that sits uneasily with the suggestion that the player is looking for an excuse not to play.

If Xhaka has a problem, it is more likely that he is trying to do too much rather than too little.

Sunderland need to manage his workload better.

His character deserves respect, but he can still get tired, especially at 34.

Copley also acknowledged that Xhaka had held serious talks with Chelsea in the summer.

However, he believes the team have already put the matter behind them.

Xhaka's behaviour after the Chelsea match was also cited in his defence.

He was one of the first onto the pitch after the final whistle, congratulated his team-mates and then celebrated the win with the team in the dressing room.

Luke O'Nien also said that Xhaka continued to help his team-mates at half-time, discussing with them how Sunderland could win the match.

He did not step aside after his injury.

He kept trying to influence the game even when he could no longer go onto the pitch.

Copley believes it is fair to discuss Xhaka's dip in form.

He noted problems with his passing, fatigue and a lack of mobility, but stressed that none of this was grounds to accuse the captain of feigning injury.

The journalist also singled out Jules Akhoku, who replaced Xhaka and had a strong game.

He believes the 20-year-old midfielder could receive more playing time, allowing Xhaka to rest more often.

The emergence of a new competitor does not mean the captain should be written off.

His form, role and place in the team can be discussed.

But accusing a player of deliberately inventing an injury is quite another matter.

Sunderland will still need his experience, quality and leadership.

Last season, Xhaka helped Sunderland finish seventh and qualify for European competition. Copley believes the captain deserves a more measured assessment despite his current dip in form.